Service Tax on Renting of Immovable Property :developments and Issues

SHARE:

Renting of Immovable property service is one among the services which has huge implication as to the coverage of number of assessees and the quantum of revenue collection. The levy came in to effect from 01-06-2007. Since renting is not a service in common parlance coupled with power to levy taxes on immovable properties is under state list, this levy created lot of ambiguity and required extensive judicial examination. All these have left behind the landlords and tenants under a puzzled situation as to compliance of the same. Therefore this article aims at giving an insight as to the development of the judicial decisions and the statutory amendments and the possible measures to be taken to obtain relief and to avoid litigation.

The definition of the taxable service as the time when levy was first introduced as defined under section 65(105)(zzzz) of the Finance Act, 1994 which read as “any service provided or to be provided to any person, by any other person in relation to renting of immovable property for use in the course or furtherance of business or commerce”.

In the case of Home Solutions Retail India Ltd vs Union of India, 2009 (237) E. L. T 0209 (Del), the Delhi High Court after due examination of the definition, gave a verdict that the definition meant to cover only “the service in relation to renting” and not “mere renting of the immovable property”. Further concluded that service tax is a value added tax and mere renting does not bring any value addition.

With this, the Government of India amended the definition of the taxable service explicitly to cover the ‘mere renting’ in the definition on 01.07.2010 with retrospective effect from 01.06.2007. The amended definition is read as “any service provided or to be provided to any person, by any other person, by renting of immovable property or any other service in relation to such renting, for use in the course of or, for furtherance of, business or commerce”

The amendment provoked Home Solutions Retail India again to knock the doors of the Delhi High Court. This time the larger bench High Court in M/s Home Solution Retail India Ltd & Others vs UOI and Ors, 2011 (21) S.T.R. 109 (Del.) has upheld the constitutional validity of the same even its retrospective amendment and further concluded that renting involves value addition.

There were other decisional of different High Courts upholding the levy in Shumb Timb Steels Ltd v. UOI 2010(20) S.T.R. 737 (P&H), Utkal Builders Ltd v. UOI, 2011(22) S.T.R. 257 (Ori), Retailers Association of India & Ors vs UOI & Ors, 2011(23) S.T.R. 566(Bom.), Cinemax India Ltd vs. UOI, 2011(24) STR 3 (Guj)

The Delhi High Court in the second Home Solution Case, while upholding the retrospective levy has stated that on the question of levying of penalty it is open to the Government to examine any waiver or exemption can be granted to the tax payers.

Consequently in the recent Union Budget, 2012-13, a new section called Section 80(2) is proposed to be introduced. Accordingly no penalty is imposable on service tax payables as on 6/03/2012 i.e. service tax payable on rents received/receivable till February, 2012, if the service tax along with interest is paid in full with in a period of six months from the date on which Finance Bill receives the assent of the President. The President assent has been received on 28.05.2012. Therefore no penalty would be leviable if the entire service tax amount along with interest has been paid on or before 28.11.2012.

In this backdrop the following questions would arise in order to seek the relief from penalty.

1. From which date the service providers are required to deposit service tax?

Comments: Since mere renting is also brought under service tax levy with retrospective amendment, service tax is payable from 01.06.2007 i.e. right from the introduction of levy.

2. Whether Small Service Provider exemption can be available?

Comments: Assessee can avail this exemption in case if the previous year value of taxable services (rental receipts & from other services) does not exceed Rs 10 lakhs. In such case the exemption up to first Rs 10 Lakhs receipts can be claimed in the next year

3. Whether deduction on payment of municipal taxes can be claimed?

Comment: Notification 24/2007 dated 22-05-2007 provides for deduction of municipal taxes paid from the value of taxable services before arriving at service tax liability. However no deduction is available for any payments by way of interest and penalties paid to local authorities on account of delayed payment or any other reasons. Further the taxes paid proportionate to the period for which service tax is paid shall alone be deducted.

Example: Property tax paid from April’2011 to March’2012 Rs 2 Lakh

Rent received for the period April’2011 to June’2011 Rs 15 Lakh

Service tax payable: 14 Lakhs (15-1) x 10%

4. How can municipal tax deduction benefit be claimed in case if theses taxes are paid subsequent to the payment of service tax?

Comment: In such cases, the municipal taxes paid can be adjusted while arriving at the service tax liability for the future in accordance with Rule 6(4c) of the Service Tax Rules, 1994. Further the claim can be made within one year from the date of payment of the property tax. The details of such adjustment shall be intimated to the concerned Superintendent of Central Excise in writing within 15 days of such adjustment.

5. How shall the service tax liability be arrived at?

Comment: For the rents that are due till 30.06.2011, service tax liability can be arrived at on receipt basis. For the rents that are payable for the period beginning from 01.07.2011, the liability shall be arrived at on monthly due basis or the date of payment whichever is earlier.

For the rents that are due till 30.06.2011, service tax liability can be arrived at on receipt basis. For the rents that are payable for the period beginning from 01.07.2011, the liability shall be arrived at on monthly due basis or the date of payment whichever is earlier.

6. What are the major capital goods, input and input services on which CENVAT Credit is available?

Comment:

1) Central Excise Duty/Additional duty of Customs (CVD) on lifts, escalators, DG sets and other facilities used in the building.

2) CED/CVD on office equipments and computers.

3) Insurance of premises, Telecommunications and other services.

7. Whether interest is payable on arrears and if so from which date onwards?

Comment: Interest is levied for not paying service tax within the due dates. In this case when the law was made on 01.07.2010 there could not be default of payment for any month/quarter prior to such date, say June 2007 service tax was required to be remitted on 5th July 2007 on which date renting was not taxable and hence the same cannot be considered non-payment. However it was clear on 01.07.2010 and hence interest has to be paid only from 01.07.2010 till the actual date of payment. This view is supported by the decision of Supreme Court in the case of Star India Pvt Ltd vs C.C.E., 2006 (1) S.T.R. 73 (SC). However in view of the paper writer, this would be definitely litigated by the Department. Considering that the payment of arrears (service tax and interest) within the time is with a view to sought relief from levy of penalties, litigation in this regard may not serve this objective. It would be worthy to fight only when the stakes involved are high.

CA Swadesh GuptaB Com (Hons), FCA, LLB, DISA
Alumni Hans Raj College (1997-2000)
Alumni Faculty of Law (Delhi University)
101 Sagar Plaza-2, Rani Bagh Comm Complex
Pitampura, New Delhi-110034
Ph: 011-47580854, Fax: 011-27020854
Mobile: 9312580854
E Mail: 
caswadeshgupta@spmg.in

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 4
Loading...
Get Latest Updates In your Inbox

$show=index

Name

. SECURITIES (MNP) (TDS)2007-08 ` 01.07.12 01.09.2008 01.10.2012 06.07.2009 07.08.2012 1 PERCENT EXCISE ITEMS LIST 1 sep 1% excise 10 year nsc 10(10C) 1000 court cases judgements supplied to ITO 1000 rupee note 11-2008 11-2010 130 items 14.08.2008 15 august 150 Rs coin 15g 15h 18-12-2009 192(1A) 192A 194 I 194A 194c from 01.10.2009 194H 194j 194LC 1981-2007 2% cst 2% excise 2004 2008 2008-09 FY 2010 206AA 234A 234B 234C 234c interest calculator 234E 23AC 23ACA 23B 24C 24q annexure II 25 paisa coin 271(1)(c) 271B 271H 272B 27A 280 280 challan 281 282 283 29 AUGUST 29.04.2010. 29/08/2008 29/2008 service tax 2g meaning use 3 idiots 30 MARCH 31st March 32-2010 33 of 2009 35(2AA) 35(2AB) 3CD 3g meaning use 40(b) 43B 44 AB EXEMPTED INCOME 44AA 44AB AGRICULTURE 44AB new limit 44AB NON RESIDENT 44ad 46/2012 45/2012 49C 5 day week 5 years post office deposit 5/2011 50 paisa coin 54b 54EC 54ee 54f 54gb 5th paycommission punjab 6 % excise 6 crore advance limit 6/2005 69/2010 6th cpc 6TH PAY COMMISSION 70% of pan etds 7th Central Pay Commission 8 tips to save tax 80C 80ccc 80CCD 80cce 80CCF 80CCG 80d 80DDB 80EE 80G 80GG 80GGA 80GGB 80ggc 80tta 80U 85% of pan etds 86/2008 DATED 13-08-2008 87A rebate 89(1) 89(1) relief calculator 9.5 % rate for private epf 92E 95% of pan etds 98 dated 04/01/08 aadhaar aakash tablet aam admi aar Aayakar Sampark Kendra abatement abolished ACCOUNT PAYEE DRAFT Accounting ACCOUNTING CODE accounting code for services ACCOUNTING FOR GOVT GRANTS accounting standards ACES ADD IN Add-Ins additional relief in budget 2010 adjustment of advance FBT with advance Tax advance rullings advance salary ADVANCE TAX CALCULATOR advance tax challan ADVANCE TAX CUT OFF AMOUNT ADVANCE TAX DATES AFFIDAVIT AG Projects Technologies Ltd RT age 80 addition pension aibea wage revision aibea wage revision latest news aiboa aiboc aiboc wage revision AIG AIR airline ticket booking tds airlines all is well allowances allownces alphabet of inspiration alteration on check allowed alternate minimum tax AMENDED 3CD amendment in companies bill 2011 amendment in gratuity act 2010 amendment in registration service tax AMENDMENT IN SERVICE TAX ON RENT amendment to finance Bill 2010 AMNESTY SCHEME 2007 amt Anna Hazare anna hazzare bill vs govt lokpal bill appeal apply for new pan card against old pan card aqb arbitration arrears of salary arrears of sixth pay ARRERS TAX AS-12 ASBA assessee in default ASSESSMENT REOPENING ASSESSMENT YEAR 2008-09 REFUND atm atm 100 per day atm cash without card atm tips atm wrong debit audit cases itr filing audit limit enhanced Audit Questionaire AUDIT REPORT AUS VS IND.INDIA VS SL Automated teller machine AUTOMATION OF CENTRAL EXCISE AND SERVICE TAX ay 2010-11 bad debts Bank Bank account bank audit bank audit 2012 bank charges BANK SALARY bank strike 06/07/09 and 07/07/09 banking law amendment banknotes banks npa provisioning BARE ACT bare rules BASE RATE BY BANKS bcct BIMAL JAIN biometric pan card black and white form not acceptable black money BLOCK PERIOD blogging bobay refund BONUS bonus share book discount BOOK ON EFILING BOOK REVIEW books of accounts BOOMING INDIAN ECONOMY both House rent allowance both hra and house loan Brass Scrap BRIBE CASE BROKER BSE bsnl broadband bsnl broadband usage bsnl land line sms alert BSR CODES BUDGET 2009 budget 2010 budget 2010-11 budget 2011 BUDGET 2012 budget 2013 BUDGET 2014 BUDGET 2014 CONTEST budget expectations BUDGET HIGHLIGHTS budget live on computer budget live telecast budget notification budget on tv budget speech BUDGET SPEECH DOWNLOAD Budget-2014 Budget-2015 BUDGET-2016 BUDGET08 Business BUSINESS AND PROFESSION MEANING BUSINESS COVERED UNDER 44ab BUY HOUSE C FORM CA CAN ONLY AUDIT MVAT CA CLUB INDIA CA GIRISH AHUJA CA NITIN GUPTA CA PARDEEP JAIN CA ROHIT GUPTA ca services CA sudhir Halakhandi CA Swapnil Munot CA Vikas Khandelwal calculate arrear CALCULATE NEW PAY calculate your emi calculation of tax on salary arrears CALCULATOR CALCULATOR REVISED capital asset capital formation huf Capital gain capital gain account scheme 1988 CAPITAL GAIN INDEX capital gain on repayment of loan capital gain on tenancy rights capital goods capital revenue CAPITAL SUBSIDY CAR LOAN RATE INCREASE carry forward of losses in late return cas cash flow statement CASH PAYMENT DIS ALLOWANCE CASH PAYMENTS EXCEEDING 20000 CASH SUBSIDY cbdt cbec CBI ARRESTED centeral sales tax rate CENTRAL PAY COMMISSION CENTRAL PROCESSING CENTER CENTRALISED PROCESSING OF RETURNS Cenvat CENVAT Credit Rules cgas 1988 challan challan 281 CHALLAN 289 challan correction challan Form 17 CHALLAN STATUS INQUIRY change change in cst rate change in excise duty rates CHANGE IN PAN ADDRESS CHANGE IN PAN DATA change in tds rates in budget changes CHANGES IN SERVICE TAX ACT changes in new itr forms CHANGES IN TDS CHARGES ON CASH PAYMENT OF CREDIT CARD BILL charitable organisation check name from PAN check tds deducted online Cheque cheque bounce cheque payment before due date cheque tender date /realisation date Cheque Truncation CHEQUE VALIDITY child care leave CHILD DEPENDENT PREMIUM CHILD MARRIED PREMIUM child plan childeren name children education allownces chip based atm card cibil cibil for companies CII 2007-08 CII 2008-09 CII 2010 cii 2012-13 CII2011-12 cin CIRCULAR 3/2010 DT 2.03.2010 CIRCULAR 8-2010 CIT v. Emilio Ruiz Berdejo (2010) 320 ITR 190 (Bom.) cloning of atm card clubbing of income COLLECTION CHARGES COLOR SCHEME COMMISSION ON SMALL SAVINGS common error in 2009-10 common error in itr 4-5-6 compa companies bill 2012 COMPANIES RATE COMPANY BILL 2011 company deposit Company Law Settlement Scheme COMPANY REGISTRATION complusory payment of taxes Composition scheme service tax COMPUTER AS FAX MACHINE computer sytem at ito office CONCEPT PAPER configure yahoo mail in outlook express consolidate account statement construction purchase of house Consultancy Service Consumer Price Index continues services CONTRIBUTION TO NEW PENSION SCHEME CONTRIBUTORY PENSION FUND CONVERT FIGURES INTO WORD EXCEL COPARCENER CorpMcash corporation bank correction etds CORRECTION IN PAN DATA correction in section CORRECTION RETURN CORRECTION RETURN.ETDS cost accounting cost audit cost inflation index cost inflation index 2012-13 COST INFLATION INDEX FY 2010-11 COST INFLATION INDEX FY 2011-12 COST OF INDEXATION CALCULATOR court case in entry tax punjab cpc phone number cpf Credit card CREDIT CARD BILL PAYMENT ICICI BANK credit scores cricket team critical illness CROSSED DEMAND DRAFT CRR crr reducred CS DIVESH GOYAL CST CST 3% OR 2 % cst act 1956 cst form CST FORM STATUS cst rate changed CST REDUCE RATE ctt currency CURRENCY TRADING ILLEGAL custom custom changes in budget cusual leave DA MERGE da rate da rate 01.07.2012 da rate january 2013 da rate july 2012 da rate wef 01.01.2012 date extension DDO ASK RENT RECIPT ddt dearness allowance Debit card DEBT EQUITY RATIO debt funds debt trap declared goods DEDUCTION 80C deduction for higher studies deduction on saving bank interst deduction u/s 80DD Deemed income of employee deemed services defective return defence officers defence pay defence pay scales DELAY IN FILING delete ledger in tally DELHI HIGH COURT demat deposit tax of two quarter in single challan depreciation depreciation on car depreciation on commercial vehicle. DEPRECIATION ON INTANGIBLE ASSETS depreciation rate depreciation rate 2009-10 DETAIL AFTER E FILLING DETAIL OF TIN Determination of value DIFFRENT TYPE OF TAXES digital signature din direct payment in bank account DIRECT SUBSIDY direct tax bill direct tax changes in budget direct tax code direct tax code 2009 Disability insurance discussion Paper distribution of salary dividend distribution tax dividend striping dnd do not call. document identification number document ientification number documents required for service tax registration domestic transfer pricing donation dot double taxation dow jones download download 89(1) relief calculator download direct tax code 2012 download form 16A download fvu download idfc INFRA BONDS FORM draft reply drawback rates dtaa dtc DUE DATE AY 2010-11 due date ay 2011-12 due date extended due date extended to 31.08.2012. due date for service tax return due date form 16 due date form 16a due date June due date march tax due date of return 2008-09 due date pf esi due date to deposit tds DUE DATES DUE DATES CALENDAR DUE DATES CALENDER DUE DATES INCOME TAX DUE DATES SERVICE TAX DUE FAMILY PENSION DULICATE PAN DUPLICATE TAN dvat e book Income Tax rules e book on service tax E ERA OF TAXES e filing do and don'ts e filing of audit report e filing processing status e filing software excel free e filing through evc e filing utilities e mode for notice to shareholder e notice to share holder e payment of epf E PAYMENT OF EXCISE DUTY e payment of income tax E PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX e payment of tds E STAMP DUTY e tutorial for TAN registration E-1 FORM E-1 SALE e-commerce E-FILE SERVICE TAX RETURN e-Intermediary e-payment from friends account E-PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX e-payment of taxes E-SEVA BY ICAI e-TDS/TCS statements earn from home earned leave Easy Exit Scheme ebay EBOOK EBOOK ON SERVICE TAX economic survey economic survey 2010 economic survey 2011 economic survey 2012 Edible Oils EDITABLE INCOME TAX FORM education cess EDUCATION LOAN eet EFFECTIVE DATE CST RATE REDUCTION effective date of allowncs efiling errors efiling free efiling income tax return efiling of excise return efiling registration problem Electricity act ELECTRONIC FOREX TRADING Electronic Verification Code (EVC) elegent card on holi ELSS EMANAGEMENT OF TAXES EMI CALCULATOR empanelment as branch auditor EMPLOYEE PROVIDENT FUND employee state insurance employee state insurance act 1948 employee state insurance act Limit employer e sewa eMudhra Consumer Services entries r off in 50 paisa entries rounded off in rs ENTRY TAX entry tax punjab epf epf challan epf claim epf e passbook EPF FAQ epf int rate 11-12 epf interest exemption epf interest rate epf interest rate for fy 2010-11 epf limit epf online EPF ONLINE CHALLAN GENERATION epf statement EPF TRUST epf withdrawals epfo equal monthly installments equity funds ER-1 ER-2 er4 form online error in etds return error in st-3 esi esi contribution esi limit 10000 esi limit 15000 esi limit from 01.05.2010 esi return ESOP ETABF ETAX etcs etds etds correction etds defualts etds due date ETDS FVU 3.1 ETDS PAYMENT ETDS Q4 ANN II etds retur with insufficient pan etds return ETDS RETURN DUE DATES etds return less dedu