$hide=Mobile

No GST on exempted services of transmission or distribution of electricity

The Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. UOI & ors. [D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9397/2018, decided on ...

The Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. UOI & ors. [D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9397/2018, decided on February 5, 2021] quashed Para 4(1) of Circular No. 34/8/2018-GST dated March 1, 2018 (“Impugned Circular”) which clarifies that following activities provided by DISCOMS to consumers are taxable:

        i.            Application fee for releasing connection of electricity;

       ii.            Rental Charges against metering equipment;

     iii.            Testing fee for meters/ transformers, capacitors etc.;

     iv.            Labour charges from customers for shifting of meters or shifting of service lines;

       v.            Charges for duplicate bill.

Further, held that, a Circular cannot seek to clarify provisions of statutory notification, which is otherwise unequivocal.

Facts:

Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd (“the Petitioner”) is a Public Sector Undertaking engaged in distribution and supply of electricity in various Districts of Rajasthan. According to the Petitioner, the services of distribution and supply of electricity fall in negative list of the services as declared by the Central Government vide Notification No.12/2017 Central Tax (Rate), dated June 28, 2017 (“Services Exemption Notification”) wherein services of transmission or distribution of electricity exempted under GST.

By filing this writ petition, the Petitioner has challenged Clause 4(1) of Impugned Circular which was issued by the Department of Revenue on the basis of recommendations of GST Council made in its meeting held on January 9, 10 and 13, 2018, by way of which, it was clarified that following activities provided by DISCOMS to consumers are taxable:

        i.            Application fee for releasing connection of electricity;

       ii.            Rental Charges against metering equipment;

     iii.            Testing fee for meters/ transformers, capacitors etc.;

     iv.            Labour charges from customers for shifting of meters or shifting of service lines;

       v.            Charges for duplicate bill.

The Petitioner contended that, once the parent exemption notification exempts the very supply and distribution of electricity, the Department of Revenue or even GST Council cannot exclude certain services by way of clarificatory circular and that all the services enumerated are nothing but a part of complete package/bundle of services, namely supply and distribution of electricity and the Impugned Circular carving out an exception and excluding some of the services, which are essential and integral part of the main function of supply and distribution of electricity is arbitrary.

Issue:

Whether GST would be leviable on various allied services of distribution and supply of electricity that are exempted by the Central Government vide Services Exemption Notification?

Held:

The Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9397/2018, decided on February 5, 2021 held as under:

·         Observed that, a simple reading of Services Exemption Notification leaves no room for ambiguity that entire package of services namely transmission or distribution of electricity has been exempted. Whereas, a perusal of Impugned Circular, reveals that the GST Council has sought to bring in tax-net five services enumerated therein, regardless of the fact that complete bundle or package of services namely transmission and distribution of electricity by an electricity transmission or distribution utility have been exempted.

·         Attempt of chipping out some of the services, out of the complete package and treating them to be taxable is not only arbitrary and unreasonable but such exercise is also violative of provisions of Section 8 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“CGST Act”).

·         Noted that, similar issue has been dealt with by the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in Torrent Power Ltd. v. Union of India [R/Special Civil Application No. 5343 of 2018, decided on December 19, 2018] wherein the Court has struck down para 4(1) of the impugned Circular being contrary to the Services Exemption Notification and ultra vires the provisions of Section 8 of the CGST Act.

·         Held that, a circular cannot seek to clarify provisions of statutory notification, which is otherwise unequivocal. There is no room for ambiguity or doubt, for which the GST Council was required to issue the circular.

·         Relied and agreed with the view taken by the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in case of Torrent Power Ltd. (supra) and quashed para 4(1) of the Impugned Circular.

·         Issued injunction and restrained the Authorities from raising any demand and/or taking any coercive measures to recover any tax on the basis of Impugned Circular.

Relevant Provisions:

Entry 25 of the Exempted Notification:

Sl. No.

Chapter, Section, Heading, Group or Service Code (Tariff)

Description of Services

Rate (per cent.)

Condition

25

Heading 9969

Transmission or distribution of electricity by an electricity transmission or distribution utility.

Nil

Nil

 

Clause 4(1) of the Impugned Circular:

S. No.

Issue

Clarification

4.

(1) Whether the activities carried by DISCOMS against recovery of charges from consumers under State Electricity Act are exempt from GST?

(1) Service by way of transmission or distribution of electricity by an electricity transmission or distribution utility is exempt from GST under notification No. 12/2017- CT (R), Sl. No. 25. The other services such as, -

     vi.            Application fee for releasing connection of electricity;

   vii.            Rental Charges against metering equipment;

 viii.            Testing fee for meters/ transformers, capacitors etc.;

     ix.            Labour charges from customers for shifting of meters or shifting of service lines;

       x.            charges for duplicate bill;

provided by DISCOMS to consumer are taxable.

 

Section 8 of the CGST Act:

“Tax liability on composite and mixed supplies-

8. The tax liability on a composite or a mixed supply shall be determined in the following manner, namely:-

(a) a composite supply comprising two or more supplies, one of which is a principal supply, shall be treated as a supply of such principal supply; and

(b) a mixed supply comprising two or more supplies shall be treated as a supply of that particular supply which attracts the highest rate of tax.

DISCLAIMER: The views expressed are strictly of the author and A2Z Taxcorp LLP. The contents of this article are solely for informational purpose. It does not constitute professional advice or recommendation of firm. Neither the author nor firm and its affiliates accepts any liabilities for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of any information in this article nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER
Name

. SECURITIES,5,(MNP),2,(TDS)2007-08,1,`,1,01.07.12,23,01.09.2008,1,01.10.2012,2,06.07.2009,3,07.08.2012,1,1 PERCENT EXCISE ITEMS LIST,2,1 sep,1,1% excise,2,10 year nsc,7,10(10C),1,10(10D),1,10(11),1,10(12),1,1000 court cases judgements supplied to ITO,7,1000 rupee note,3,11-2008,1,11-2010,1,111A,2,130 items,1,14.08.2008,1,15 august,2,150 Rs coin,2,15g,14,15h,15,18-12-2009,1,192(1A),5,192A,2,194 I,3,194 IA,1,194A,7,194c from 01.10.2009,7,194H,6,194j,15,194LC,3,194N,1,194O,1,194q,2,1981-2007,2,2% cst,1,2% excise,1,2004,1,2008,1,2008-09 FY,1,2010,2,206AA,14,234A 234B 234C,10,234c interest calculator,11,234D,1,234E,16,234F,2,23AC,1,23ACA,1,23B,2,24C,3,24q annexure II,5,25 paisa coin,1,271(1)(c),5,271B,2,271H,4,272B,1,27A,1,280,5,280 challan,4,281,4,282,2,283,2,29 AUGUST,2,29.04.2010.,1,29/08/2008,2,29/2008 service tax,2,2g meaning use,1,3 idiots,1,30 MARCH,4,31st March,19,32-2010,1,33 of 2009,1,35(2AA),1,35(2AB),1,3CD,18,3g meaning use,1,40(b),4,43B,5,44 AB EXEMPTED INCOME,1,44AA,1,44AB AGRICULTURE,2,44AB new limit,29,44AB NON RESIDENT,3,44ad,19,44ada,3,46/2012 45/2012,1,49C,1,5 day week,1,5 years post office deposit,5,5/2011,1,50 paisa coin,2,500-1000 notes banned,128,54b,19,54EC,28,54ee,1,54f,22,54gb,1,5th paycommission punjab,1,6 % excise,1,6 crore advance limit,1,6/2005,1,69/2010,1,6th cpc,5,6TH PAY COMMISSION,6,70% of pan etds,7,7th Central Pay Commission,12,8 tips to save tax,2,80C,90,80ccc,3,80CCD,16,80cce,2,80CCF,18,80CCG,6,80d,10,80DDB,14,80EE,4,80EEA,1,80G,6,80GG,8,80GGA,6,80GGB,1,80ggc,1,80tta,5,80TTB,2,80U,2,85% of pan etds,1,86/2008 DATED 13-08-2008,1,87A rebate,9,89(1),22,89(1) relief calculator,19,9.5 % rate for private epf,8,92E,1,95% of pan etds,5,98 dated 04/01/08,1,aadhaar,18,aakash tablet,1,aam admi,1,aar,4,Aayakar Sampark Kendra,1,abatement,13,abolished,1,ACCOUNT PAYEE DRAFT,2,Accounting,1,ACCOUNTING CODE,11,accounting code for services,6,ACCOUNTING FOR GOVT GRANTS,3,accounting standards,12,ACES,10,ADD IN,1,Add-Ins,2,additional relief in budget 2010,1,adjustment of advance FBT with advance Tax,2,advance rullings,3,advance salary,2,advance tax,2,ADVANCE TAX CALCULATOR,10,advance tax challan,19,advance tax collections,1,ADVANCE TAX CUT OFF AMOUNT,12,ADVANCE TAX DATES,20,AFFIDAVIT,2,affordable housing,1,AG Projects Technologies Ltd RT,1,age 80 addition pension,2,aibea wage revision,1,aibea wage revision latest news,1,aiboa,1,aiboc,1,aiboc wage revision,1,AIG,1,AIR,10,airline ticket booking tds,7,airlines,3,all is well,1,allowances,5,allownces,4,alphabet of inspiration,1,alteration on check allowed,3,alternate minimum tax,4,AMENDED 3CD,12,amendment in companies bill 2011,2,amendment in gratuity act 2010,5,amendment in registration service tax,4,AMENDMENT IN SERVICE TAX ON RENT,6,amendment to finance Bill 2010,1,AMNESTY SCHEME 2007,2,amt,2,Anna Hazare,2,anna hazzare bill vs govt lokpal bill,1,appeal,15,apply for new pan card against old pan card,3,aqb,1,arbitration,2,arrears of salary,5,arrears of sixth pay,6,ARRERS TAX,2,AS-12,1,ASBA,1,assessee in default,2,ASSESSMENT REOPENING,8,ASSESSMENT YEAR 2008-09 REFUND,1,atm,13,atm 100 per day,2,atm cash without card,2,atm tips,9,atm wrong debit,1,audit cases itr filing,2,audit limit enhanced,13,Audit Questionaire,1,AUDIT REPORT,63,AUS VS IND.INDIA VS SL,1,Automated teller machine,1,AUTOMATION OF CENTRAL EXCISE AND SERVICE TAX,7,Axis Bank credit cards,2,ay 2010-11,1,bad debts,2,Balwant Jain,180,Bank,6,Bank account,15,bank audit,3,bank audit 2012,1,bank charges,19,BANK SALARY,2,bank strike 06/07/09 and 07/07/09,1,banking law amendment,1,banknotes,6,banks npa provisioning,4,BARE ACT,4,bare rules,1,BASE RATE BY BANKS,2,bcct,1,belated return,3,benami property,1,BIMAL JAIN,476,biometric pan card,3,black and white form not acceptable,2,black money,27,BLOCK PERIOD,1,blogging,1,bobay refund,1,BONUS,2,bonus share,2,book discount,5,BOOK ON EFILING,1,BOOK REVIEW,1,books of accounts,6,BOOMING INDIAN ECONOMY,3,both House rent allowance,10,both hra and house loan,15,Brass Scrap,3,BRIBE CASE,1,BROKER,3,BSE,1,bsnl broadband,1,bsnl broadband usage,1,bsnl land line sms alert,2,BSR CODES,3,BUDGET 2009,18,budget 2010,28,budget 2010-11,4,budget 2011,13,BUDGET 2012,38,budget 2013,17,BUDGET 2014,39,BUDGET 2014 CONTEST,6,budget 24-25,5,budget expectations,8,BUDGET HIGHLIGHTS,11,budget live on computer,5,budget live telecast,5,budget notification,1,budget on tv,1,budget speech,16,BUDGET SPEECH DOWNLOAD,2,Budget-2014,2,Budget-2015,45,BUDGET-2016,71,budget-2017,28,BUDGET-2018,32,BUDGET-2019,22,BUDGET-2020,2,budget-2022,9,BUDGET-21,39,Budget-23,51,Budget-25,16,BUDGET08,5,BUDGET2018,1,Business,5,BUSINESS AND PROFESSION MEANING,1,BUSINESS COVERED UNDER 44ab,2,buy back,1,BUY HOUSE,5,C FORM,5,CA CAN ONLY AUDIT MVAT,4,CA CLUB INDIA,1,CA GIRISH AHUJA,3,CA NITIN GUPTA,5,CA PARDEEP JAIN,5,CA ROHIT GUPTA,4,ca services,3,CA sudhir Halakhandi,1,CA Swapnil Munot,15,CA Vikas Khandelwal,9,calculate arrear,1,CALCULATE NEW PAY,2,calculate your emi,4,calculation of tax on salary arrears,4,CALCULATOR,72,CALCULATOR REVISED,1,capital asset,4,capital formation huf,3,Capital gain,45,capital gain account scheme 1988,11,CAPITAL GAIN INDEX,30,capital gain on repayment of loan,2,capital gain on tenancy rights,1,capital goods,3,capital revenue,1,CAPITAL SUBSIDY,3,CAR LOAN,1,CAR LOAN RATE INCREASE,12,carry forward of losses in late return,5,cas,1,cash back,1,Cash credit,2,cash flow statement,1,CASH PAYMENT DIS ALLOWANCE,11,CASH PAYMENTS EXCEEDING 20000,5,CASH SUBSIDY,3,Cash Transaction 2016,8,cbdt,15,cbec,9,CBI ARRESTED,1,centeral sales tax rate,2,CENTRAL PAY COMMISSION,6,CENTRAL PROCESSING CENTER,2,CENTRALISED PROCESSING OF RETURNS,1,Cenvat,63,CENVAT Credit Rules,81,cgas 1988,3,challan,7,challan 281,10,CHALLAN 289,1,challan correction,8,challan Form 17,11,CHALLAN STATUS INQUIRY,1,change,1,change in cst rate,5,change in excise duty rates,11,CHANGE IN PAN ADDRESS,3,CHANGE IN PAN DATA,7,change in tds rates in budget,14,changes,2,CHANGES IN SERVICE TAX ACT,58,changes in Gst,1,changes in income tax,2,changes in new itr forms,11,CHANGES IN TDS,14,CHARGES ON CASH PAYMENT OF CREDIT CARD BILL,3,charitable organisation,5,check name from PAN,2,check tds deducted online,3,Cheque,12,cheque bounce,7,cheque payment before due date,8,cheque tender date /realisation date,4,Cheque Truncation,7,CHEQUE VALIDITY,9,child care leave,3,CHILD DEPENDENT PREMIUM,1,CHILD MARRIED PREMIUM,1,child plan,1,childeren name,1,children education allownces,10,chip based atm card,4,cibil,13,cibil for companies,5,CII 2007-08,1,CII 2008-09,2,CII 2010,1,cii 2012-13,1,CII2011-12,1,cin,2,CIRCULAR 3/2010 DT 2.03.2010,1,CIRCULAR 8-2010,1,CIT v. Emilio Ruiz Berdejo (2010) 320 ITR 190 (Bom.),1,cloning of atm card,1,clubbing of income,2,co-ownership,1,COLLECTION CHARGES,1,COLOR SCHEME,1,COMMISSION ON SMALL SAVINGS,2,common error in 2009-10,1,common error in itr 4-5-6,3,compa,1,companies bill 2012,2,COMPANIES RATE,2,COMPANY BILL 2011,6,company deposit,5,Company Law Settlement Scheme,5,COMPANY REGISTRATION,4,complusory payment of taxes,1,Composite rent,1,COMPOSITE SUPPLY,3,Composition scheme GST,15,Composition scheme service tax,2,compounding of offence,1,COMPUTER AS FAX MACHINE,1,computer sytem at ito office,1,CONCEPT PAPER,1,configure yahoo mail in outlook express,7,consolidate account statement,5,construction purchase of house,9,Consultancy Service,2,consumer loans,2,Consumer Price Index,2,consumer protection,1,continues services,1,CONTRIBUTION TO NEW PENSION SCHEME,10,CONTRIBUTORY PENSION FUND,3,CONVERT FIGURES INTO WORD EXCEL,8,COPARCENER,1,CORONA,8,CorpMcash,1,Corporate Social Responsibility,1,corporate tax,1,corporation bank,3,correction etds,10,CORRECTION IN PAN DATA,8,correction in section,4,CORRECTION RETURN,6,CORRECTION RETURN.ETDS,7,cost accounting,5,cost audit,6,cost inflation index,21,cost inflation index 2012-13,2,COST INFLATION INDEX FY 2010-11,1,COST INFLATION INDEX FY 2011-12,1,COST OF INDEXATION CALCULATOR,5,court case in entry tax punjab,2,covid-19,3,cpc phone number,6,cpf,7,Credit card,32,CREDIT CARD BILL PAYMENT ICICI BANK,6,credit scores,14,cricket team,1,critical illness,1,CROSSED DEMAND DRAFT,2,CRR,14,crr reducred,1,cryptocurrency,1,CS DIVESH GOYAL,69,CST,12,CST 3% OR 2 %,3,cst act 1956,1,cst form,6,CST FORM STATUS,1,cst rate changed,3,CST REDUCE RATE,4,ctt,3,currency,2,CURRENCY TRADING ILLEGAL,1,custom,4,custom changes in budget,18,cusual leave,1,DA MERGE,2,da rate,16,da rate 01.07.2012,4,da rate january 2013,4,da rate july 2012,3,da rate wef 01.01.2012,4,date extension,4,DDO ASK RENT RECIPT,1,ddt,4,dearness allowance,15,Debit card,11,DEBT EQUITY RATIO,1,debt funds,13,debt trap,3,declared goods,1,DEDUCTION 80C,6,deduction for higher studies,3,deduction on saving bank interst,2,deduction u/s 80DD,6,Deemed income of employee,1,deemed ownership,1,deemed services,1,defective return,4,defence officers,1,defence pay,1,defence pay scales,2,DELAY IN FILING,3,delete ledger in tally,1,DELHI HIGH COURT,11,demat,4,deposit tax of two quarter in single challan,3,depreciation,15,depreciation on car,3,depreciation on commercial vehicle.,2,DEPRECIATION ON INTANGIBLE ASSETS,3,depreciation rate,13,depreciation rate 2009-10,3,DETAIL AFTER E FILLING,1,DETAIL OF TIN,1,Determination of value,1,DIFFRENT TYPE OF TAXES,1,digital signature,10,din,4,direct payment in bank account,1,DIRECT SUBSIDY,10,direct tax bill,6,direct tax changes in budget,25,direct tax code,39,direct tax code 2009,6,dis,1,Disability insurance,4,discussion Paper,4,distribution of salary,2,dividend distribution tax,2,dividend striping,1,dnd,1,do not call.,1,document identification number,1,document ientification number,1,documents required for service tax registration,5,domestic transfer pricing,5,donation,3,dot,1,double taxation,1,dow jones,1,download,1,download 89(1) relief calculator,12,download direct tax code 2012,10,download form 16A,7,download fvu,28,download idfc INFRA BONDS FORM,1,draft reply,1,drawback rates,2,dtaa,4,dtc,10,DUE DATE AY 2010-11,2,due date ay 2011-12,3,due date extended,72,due date extended to 31.08.2012.,2,due date for service tax return,36,due date form 16,21,due date form 16a,10,due date June,2,due date march tax,11,due date of return 2008-09,3,due date pf esi,6,due date to deposit tds,15,DUE DATES,17,DUE DATES CALENDAR,8,DUE DATES CALENDER,9,DUE DATES INCOME TAX,23,DUE DATES SERVICE TAX,42,DUE FAMILY PENSION,1,DULICATE PAN,1,DUPLICATE TAN,5,dvat,8,e book Income Tax rules,3,e book on service tax,22,E ERA OF TAXES,1,e filing do and don'ts,7,e filing of audit report,10,e filing processing status,8,e filing software excel free,4,e filing through evc,10,e filing utilities,6,e mode for notice to shareholder,1,e notice to share holder,1,e payment of epf,5,E PAYMENT OF EXCISE DUTY,2,e payment of income tax,5,E PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX,4,e payment of tds,8,E STAMP DUTY,1,e tutorial for TAN registration,3,E-1 FORM,1,E-1 SALE,6,e-commerce,1,E-FILE SERVICE TAX RETURN,18,e-Intermediary,1,e-payment from friends account,2,E-PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX,9,e-payment of taxes,6,E-SEVA BY ICAI,4,e-TDS/TCS statements,2,E-WAY-BILL,15,earn from home,1,earned leave,2,Easy Exit Scheme,1,ebay,1,EBOOK,75,EBOOK ON SERVICE TAX,23,economic survey,9,economic survey 2010,3,economic survey 2011,2,economic survey 2012,1,Edible Oils,1,EDITABLE INCOME TAX FORM,1,education cess,6,EDUCATION LOAN,5,eet,4,EFFECTIVE DATE CST RATE REDUCTION,2,effective date of allowncs,2,efiling errors,5,efiling free,2,efiling income tax return,31,efiling of excise return,6,efiling registration problem,18,electric vehicle,1,Electricity act,2,ELECTRONIC FOREX TRADING,1,Electronic Gold Receipts,1,Electronic Verification Code (EVC),10,elegent card on holi,1,ELSS,20,EMANAGEMENT OF TAXES,1,EMI CALCULATOR,8,empanelment as branch auditor,2,EMPLOYEE PROVIDENT FUND,9,employee state insurance,2,employee state insurance act 1948,1,employee state insurance act Limit,1,employer e sewa,4,eMudhra Consumer Services,1,entries r off in 50 paisa,1,entries rounded off in rs,1,ENTRY TAX,5,
ltr
item
SIMPLE TAX INDIA: No GST on exempted services of transmission or distribution of electricity
No GST on exempted services of transmission or distribution of electricity
SIMPLE TAX INDIA
https://www.simpletaxindia.net/2021/03/no-gst-on-exempted-services-of-transmission-distribution-electricity.html
https://www.simpletaxindia.net/
https://www.simpletaxindia.net/
https://www.simpletaxindia.net/2021/03/no-gst-on-exempted-services-of-transmission-distribution-electricity.html
true
2004257931445490362
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content